Monday, September 14, 2009

And in the Darkness Bind Them ...

I used to watch the 700 Club once in a while for a good laugh*.

One of their more common segments was how "(insert name) had a hole in their heart, was doing all sorts of self-destructive things, and then came to find salvation in Jesus. You, too, have a hole in your heart. You know it's there ... a hollow place that's looking for meaning. You can find this meaning in Jesus Christ!"

Christianity is a movement that responded to the increased sense of disconnection felt by members of the aggressive culture that was spreading throughout the middle east.

As developed over 3 centuries, Christianity differentiated itself from Judaism by asserting that although you're an awful terrible sinner, that a god (one of your betters, which you learned from an early age was an important thing to keep track of) has sacrificed himself so that you can be saved.

The sense of disconnection you feel? A pang of guilt over the culture you're participating in, the pain of backbreaking labor? All of this is easily explained -- this life is meant to be painful and cruel. Your eternal reward comes when you die, but only if you play along while you're still alive.

There are many adaptations in our culture that account for, and even justify the sense of disconnection we feel. As you might expect, these memes have evolved to become quite powerful over the past 2,000 years. These concepts are often so deeply embedded into our culture, that it's a bit difficult to recognize them sometimes.


===

* Yes yes, I know ... I used to get a good laugh from tracking the exploits of right-wing nutcases. I have an odd sense of humor! :)

3 Comments, Post a Comment:

Joel said...

Reminds me a bit of the analysis of Ayn Rand that The Nation did recently (the link I supplied in "comment as").

I was brought up with a variety of Christianity that opposes empire, seeks to build empathy and community power, and focuses on development away from the choices of pre-packaged identity on offer from the wealthy and powerful. It doesn't exist on TV, but I think such a strain of belief has been there all along.

Erik said...

Thanks for the link. To clarify, I would differentiate between religion as a matter of faith ... and religion as a method of social control.

Though appealing to the frustration of people engaged in backbreaking labor, Christianity's promise of a better life was quite powerful. It became another way of keeping people in line.

This is particularly sad, because the bits I remember in the bible are about "loving thy neighbor" and "kicking greedy capitalists out of the temple".

Joel said...

"Greedy capitalist" isn't really the core of it.

The people kicked out of the temple were spiritual money-launderers: they took dirty Roman money (officially, the problem was graven images of a pagan God, i.e. the emperor), and gave "clean" stuff suitable to offer at the temple, pigeons or blank slabs of silver boullion etc.

You only get Roman money by collaborating with the occupiers who are oppressing your people. It's frustrating when people who have done that are accommodated by the temple authorities, in willfull ignorance of the damage done by buying into the oppressive systems of empire. Apparently, frustrating enough to inspire violence from one of the most ideologically non-violent people around...

I agree it's particularly sad. I just re-discovered this article by Walter Wink, which I think more Christians should read.